Comparison of summer tires R17, test

Pin
Send
Share
Send

The content of the article:

  1. Is testing worth believing
  2. Varieties of tires and the results of their testing
    • Tires 225/50 R17
    • Tires 215/55 R17
    • Tires 225/60 R17
    • Tires 225/65 R17
    • Crossover tires


R17 summer tires are regularly tested by various companies. Many of these tests are considered corrupt by motorists, some are believed, and others are ignored. But in any case, familiarization with the information and comparison of the data obtained will not be superfluous.

Is testing worth believing

A couple of years ago, several of the leading brands in the market were seen in a kind of falsification - the companies manufactured a limited number of products specifically for testing. Naturally, these tires differed in quality from those that went on sale. No one undertakes to assert that a frank marriage was "leaked" to the shelves, but any statistics (and the rating of summer R17 tires as well) raised doubts about the reality.

After this turn of events, companies that conduct autotests, in most cases, began to buy tires in ordinary stores, and not use those provided by the manufacturer. This approach makes it possible to exclude at least fraud on the part of the manufacturer.

Varieties of tires and the results of their testing

The test procedure consists of several stages. Tires are tested for maneuverability in various weather conditions, grip level, off-road ability, etc. The test of summer tires R17 was done by many companies and at various polygons. The results of each test are different, but mainly proven reliable brands such as Pirelli, Michelin, etc. occupy the leading positions.

Summer tires 225/50 R17

The statistics of this category of tire products once again confirm that proven brands have undeniable advantages.

Several popular models proved to be the best in the tests.

Continental SportContact 5

Advantages:

  • high-quality adhesion to the road surface;
  • clear movement on the track with high humidity;
  • the most efficient handling;
  • low degree of noise.


Disadvantages:

  • increased resistance to movement.

Dunlop Spart BluResponse

The products have an asymmetric tread and a drainage system made of longitudinal and transverse grooves. The manufacturer adds special polymer particles to the rubber composition, which serve to improve the adhesion properties.

Advantages:

  • accurate steering performance in various weather conditions;
  • perfect handling on dry surfaces;
  • low rolling resistance;
  • short braking distance on a dry surface.


Disadvantages:

  • low level of resistance to aquaplaning;
  • Slow steering response when cornering.

Hankook Ventus V12 evo2 K120

To increase the level of grip on the surface, the manufacturer produces tires made from specially developed rubber with the addition of silicon particles. The tread pattern is wing-shaped, which helps to reduce noise.

Advantages:

  • clear sensation of the surface in "wet" conditions;
  • minimum braking distance;
  • wear resistance;
  • low noise level.


Disadvantages:

  • low level of resistance to longitudinal planning;
  • strong resistance to movement.

Summer tires 215/55 R17

Auto Zeitung magazine conducted a fresh test of 17 "summer tires, highlighting the most promising options and examining all the features of each sample.

Michelin primacy 3

In the Auto Zeitung test for 2017, this model showed the best results in almost all indicators: aquaplaning, grip, handling. The only significant drawback is the strong rolling resistance.

Adhesion to the surface in conditions of high humidity is slightly lower than desired, but on a dry surface it does not cause any complaints; it is close to perfect.

The disadvantages include fuzzy controllability in the process of maneuvering.

Continental ContiPremiumaContact 5

These are the best summer tires R17 in terms of quality characteristics after Michelin. Testing has shown excellent handling and lateral stability on dry surfaces. But the braking distance on dry asphalt could be shorter.

Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance

The products distinguished themselves by the smallest braking distance among all tested items. Also tires have a low level of rolling resistance.

The disadvantages include a slow response to steering and an insufficient steering angle on dry asphalt.

Pirelli Cinturato P7 Blue

This model has one significant drawback - low resistance to aquaplaning.
But handling and short braking length, both on dry and wet roads, are the strengths of Pirelli.

Summer tires 225/60 R17

The Australian company Choice has carried out autotests for several types of tires with the given sizes 225/60 R17. The choice was due to the fact that these tires are the most versatile among the variety of narrowly targeted models for SUV cars.

The first places according to the results of the tests were taken (as expected) by popular and proven brands.

Pirelli Cinturato P7

Summer tires R17 225 with symmetrical tread have proven themselves in such disciplines as noise level, braking distance and cornering in wet and dry conditions.

Goodyear EfficientGrip SUV

The model took second place, just behind Pirelli.

Summer tires 225/65 R17

The popularity and quality of such brands as Continetal or Pirelli is beyond doubt, and only equally popular and proven brands can compete with them.

Michelin Latitude Cross

Combines the qualities of SUVs and off-road tires. They have almost perfect grip characteristics and increased wear resistance. Rain, mud, stones - all this the car overcomes thanks to the presence of cutting edges on the tread, made by analogy with the winter version. The special curvature of the tread pattern contributes to the reduction of the noise level.

The tires have good handling, maneuverability and resistance to aquaplaning. The disadvantages include only an increase in the braking distance on a wet road surface.

Yokohama parada spec-x

The model is distinguished by a pronounced tread and directional pattern. Products are resistant to mechanical damage and temperature extremes. Ideal for high-performance SUVs and off-road use as the tread provides optimal traction. The only thing many motorists complain about are small stones stuck in the grooves of the tread pattern.

Kumho Sens KR26

The tire tread is extended for increased performance, while the specially designed thin plates reduce noise and provide a smooth ride. The car feels confident both on wet and dry roads, with directional driving and in the process of maneuvering.

Falken Ziex ZE912

These tires came in third, performing above average and leaving behind brands such as Nexen, Hankook, Maxxis, Yokohama and others.

Crossover tires

Crossovers are in increasing demand every year, despite the fact that their cost is higher than the level of budget cars. Thanks to the design features, the crossovers are versatile and equally good both for driving on asphalt and off-road conditions.

This state of affairs requires specially designed tires that are suitable for various operating conditions, whether it's asphalt or dirt on country roads. Testing tires for crossovers is somewhat different from testing "lightweight" tires for standard passenger cars.They must have perfect grip, good handling in bad weather and other characteristics.

The German auto magazine "Auto Motor und Sport" regularly tests tires from various manufacturers. The 2016 R17 summer crossover tires were tested with 9 tire products.

Linglong Greenmax 4 × 4 HP

Manufacturer: China.

The most unfortunate variant of those involved in the tests. The tires did not pass testing, showing themselves in almost all "nominations" from the worst side.

Pros:

  • low price.


Minuses:

  • too long (the longest of all tested) braking distance, and not only on a wet, but also on a dry surface;
  • rolling resistance;
  • low level of controllability;
  • poor adhesion to the surface, especially in "rainy" conditions.

Toyo Proxes CV 2 SUV

Manufacturer: Japan.

In terms of their performance, they almost did not surpass the Chinese Linglong. Long braking, poor grip, almost zero aquaplaning resistance.

Pros:

  • minimal noise accompaniment;
  • rolling resistance.

Bridgestone Turanza T001

Manufacturer: Spain.

The results are similar to the previous version.

Pros:

  • low noise level;
  • minimal resistance to movement.


Minuses:

  • long braking distance;
  • reduced resistance to aquaplaning;
  • handling is below average;
  • low level of adhesion to the surface.

Nokian Line SUV

Manufacturer: Finland.

Showed an average result across all tests. The average indicators correspond to the price range - the cost of the goods of this company is quite acceptable.

Falken Ziex ZE914 Eco Run

Manufacturer: Japan.

Like the previous version, the tires of this company have average results in all indicators, including price.

The best performance according to "Auto Motor und Sport"

Continental ContiPremiumContact 5

The products have been designed to maximize traction whatever the driving style.

Pros:

  • optimal grip on any road surface and in all weather conditions;
  • low resistance to movement;
  • optimal handling.


Minuses:

  • minor deviations during operation in extreme conditions.

Michelin primacy 3

Tires of this brand have smooth edges, which allows them to adhere to the surface as closely as possible. Also, the design assumes the presence of self-locking lamellas.

Pros:

  • the most effective grip on the road surface, both dry and wet;
  • high level of controllability;
  • short braking distance;
  • precise cornering and maneuverability.


Cons: not significant.

Pirelli Skorpion Verde

Asymmetrically designed tires. Their release began in 2010 and after a few years Skorpion Verde still keep the bar and are in demand.
Tires of this line were developed with an emphasis on high-speed driving, which affected their design features.

Pros:

  • durability;
  • good adhesion to the surface;
  • resistance to mechanical damage;
  • handling on wet and dry surfaces.


Cons: not significant.

Goodyear EfficientGrip SUV

Goodyear EfficientGrip SUV tires won by a small margin.
They feature a non-directional protector, which simplifies the installation process.

Pros:

  • optimal contact with the road surface;
  • short braking distance;
  • optimal handling in conditions of high humidity and on dry road surfaces;
  • minimal noise accompaniment;
  • off-road patency;
  • resistance to mechanical damage.


Minuses:

  • on a damp surface, the braking distance is increased.


To choose summer tires R17 for crossovers and other categories of cars, you should study not only the testing ratings, but also read the reviews of car owners.

Even truthful tests are not always able to reveal all the shortcomings and features of the product, because much depends not only on the quality of the tire itself, but also on the operating conditions.

Pin
Send
Share
Send